| Arkansas State | SP+ -11.6 | #105 |
| Southern Miss | SP+ -20.7 | #128 |
| 2025 | Southern Miss 27 – 21 Arkansas State |
| 2024 | Arkansas State 44 – 28 Southern Miss |
| 2023 | Southern Miss 37 – 44 Arkansas State |
| 2022 | Arkansas State 19 – 20 Southern Miss |
| 2008 | Southern Miss 27 – 24 Arkansas State |
| 2007 | Arkansas State 10 – 16 Southern Miss |
| 2005 | Southern Miss 31 – 19 Arkansas State |
| 1979 | Arkansas State 6 – 14 Southern Miss |