| Western Kentucky | SP+ -7.3 | #94 |
| Middle Tennessee | SP+ -26.5 | #135 |
| 2025 | Middle Tennessee 26 – 42 Western Kentucky |
| 2024 | Western Kentucky 49 – 21 Middle Tennessee |
| 2023 | Middle Tennessee 10 – 31 Western Kentucky |
| 2022 | Western Kentucky 35 – 17 Middle Tennessee |
| 2021 | Middle Tennessee 21 – 48 Western Kentucky |
| 2020 | Western Kentucky 20 – 17 Middle Tennessee |
| 2019 | Middle Tennessee 26 – 31 Western Kentucky |
| 2018 | Western Kentucky 10 – 29 Middle Tennessee |