| Troy | SP+ -8.0 | #97 |
| Arkansas State | SP+ -11.6 | #105 |
| 2025 | Arkansas State 23 – 10 Troy |
| 2024 | Troy 31 – 34 Arkansas State |
| 2023 | Arkansas State 3 – 37 Troy |
| 2022 | Troy 48 – 19 Arkansas State |
| 2020 | Troy 38 – 10 Arkansas State |
| 2019 | Arkansas State 50 – 43 Troy |
| 2017 | Troy 32 – 25 Arkansas State |
| 2016 | Arkansas State 35 – 3 Troy |