| UL Monroe | SP+ -28.9 | #136 |
| Arkansas State | SP+ -11.6 | #105 |
| 2025 | Arkansas State 16 – 28 UL Monroe |
| 2024 | UL Monroe 21 – 28 Arkansas State |
| 2023 | Arkansas State 34 – 24 UL Monroe |
| 2022 | UL Monroe 28 – 45 Arkansas State |
| 2021 | Arkansas State 27 – 24 UL Monroe |
| 2020 | UL Monroe 15 – 48 Arkansas State |
| 2019 | Arkansas State 48 – 41 UL Monroe |
| 2018 | UL Monroe 17 – 31 Arkansas State |