| Central Michigan | SP+ -15.1 | #119 |
| Buffalo | SP+ -12.7 | #111 |
| 2025 | Buffalo 19 – 38 Central Michigan |
| 2023 | Central Michigan 13 – 37 Buffalo |
| 2022 | Buffalo 27 – 31 Central Michigan |
| 2019 | Central Michigan 20 – 43 Buffalo |
| 2018 | Buffalo 34 – 24 Central Michigan |
| 2015 | Buffalo 14 – 51 Central Michigan |
| 2014 | Central Michigan 20 – 14 Buffalo |
| 2009 | Central Michigan 20 – 13 Buffalo |