| Massachusetts | SP+ -32.9 | #138 |
| Buffalo | SP+ -12.7 | #111 |
| 2025 | Buffalo 28 – 21 Massachusetts |
| 2024 | Massachusetts 3 – 34 Buffalo |
| 2022 | Buffalo 34 – 7 Massachusetts |
| 2015 | Massachusetts 31 – 26 Buffalo |
| 2014 | Buffalo 41 – 21 Massachusetts |
| 2013 | Massachusetts 3 – 32 Buffalo |
| 2012 | Buffalo 29 – 19 Massachusetts |
| 1970 | Massachusetts 13 – 16 Buffalo |