| Virginia | SP+ 8.1 | #37 |
| Florida State | SP+ 9.1 | #35 |
| 2025 | Florida State 38 – 46 Virginia |
| 2019 | Florida State 24 – 31 Virginia |
| 2014 | Virginia 20 – 34 Florida State |
| 2011 | Virginia 14 – 13 Florida State |
| 2010 | Florida State 34 – 14 Virginia |
| 2006 | Virginia 0 – 33 Florida State |
| 2005 | Florida State 21 – 26 Virginia |
| 2004 | Virginia 3 – 36 Florida State |