| 2013 | Nicholls 24 – 49 Sam Houston |
| 2012 | Sam Houston 41 – 0 Nicholls |
| 2011 | Nicholls 7 – 47 Sam Houston |
| 2010 | Sam Houston 26 – 7 Nicholls |
| 2009 | Nicholls 21 – 44 Sam Houston |
| 2006 | Nicholls 7 – 37 Sam Houston |
| 2005 | Sam Houston 17 – 37 Nicholls |
| 2004 | Nicholls 10 – 38 Sam Houston |