| Georgia Southern | SP+ -10.8 | #103 |
| Troy | SP+ -8.0 | #97 |
| 2024 | Troy 28 – 20 Georgia Southern |
| 2021 | Georgia Southern 24 – 27 Troy |
| 2020 | Troy 13 – 20 Georgia Southern |
| 2019 | Georgia Southern 28 – 49 Troy |
| 2018 | Troy 35 – 21 Georgia Southern |
| 2017 | Georgia Southern 16 – 38 Troy |
| 2016 | Troy 24 – 28 Georgia Southern |
| 2015 | Georgia Southern 45 – 10 Troy |