| 2023 | App State 41 – 40 UL Monroe |
| 2021 | UL Monroe 28 – 59 App State |
| 2020 | App State 31 – 13 UL Monroe |
| 2019 | UL Monroe 7 – 52 App State |
| 2017 | App State 45 – 52 UL Monroe |
| 2016 | UL Monroe 17 – 42 App State |
| 2015 | App State 59 – 14 UL Monroe |
| 2014 | UL Monroe 29 – 31 App State |