| App State | SP+ -12.7 | #111 |
| Coastal Carolina | SP+ -14.7 | #117 |
| 2025 | Coastal Carolina 45 – 37 App State |
| 2024 | App State 24 – 38 Coastal Carolina |
| 2023 | Coastal Carolina 27 – 24 App State |
| 2022 | App State 28 – 35 Coastal Carolina |
| 2021 | Coastal Carolina 27 – 30 App State |
| 2020 | App State 23 – 34 Coastal Carolina |
| 2019 | Coastal Carolina 37 – 56 App State |
| 2018 | App State 23 – 7 Coastal Carolina |