| Old Dominion | SP+ -6.9 | #93 |
| App State | SP+ -12.7 | #111 |
| 2025 | App State 21 – 24 Old Dominion |
| 2024 | Old Dominion 20 – 28 App State |
| 2023 | App State 21 – 28 Old Dominion |
| 2022 | Old Dominion 14 – 27 App State |
| 2016 | Old Dominion 7 – 31 App State |
| 2015 | App State 49 – 0 Old Dominion |