| 2022 | Gardner-Webb 20 – 21 Liberty |
| 2014 | Gardner-Webb 0 – 34 Liberty |
| 2013 | Liberty 24 – 0 Gardner-Webb |
| 2011 | Liberty 35 – 3 Gardner-Webb |
| 2010 | Gardner-Webb 14 – 40 Liberty |
| 2008 | Gardner-Webb 10 – 30 Liberty |
| 2007 | Liberty 31 – 0 Gardner-Webb |
| 2006 | Gardner-Webb 27 – 24 Liberty |