| 2014 | Jacksonville State 20 – 6 Eastern Kentucky |
| 2012 | Jacksonville State 21 – 51 Eastern Kentucky |
| 2011 | Eastern Kentucky 52 – 48 Jacksonville State |
| 2010 | Jacksonville State 37 – 49 Eastern Kentucky |
| 2009 | Eastern Kentucky 26 – 34 Jacksonville State |
| 2008 | Jacksonville State 35 – 38 Eastern Kentucky |
| 2007 | Eastern Kentucky 31 – 20 Jacksonville State |
| 2006 | Jacksonville State 28 – 0 Eastern Kentucky |