| Eastern Michigan | SP+ -16.1 | #122 |
| Western Michigan | SP+ -6.0 | #90 |
| 2025 | Western Michigan 31 – 21 Eastern Michigan |
| 2024 | Eastern Michigan 18 – 26 Western Michigan |
| 2023 | Western Michigan 45 – 21 Eastern Michigan |
| 2022 | Eastern Michigan 45 – 23 Western Michigan |
| 2021 | Western Michigan 21 – 22 Eastern Michigan |
| 2020 | Eastern Michigan 53 – 42 Western Michigan |
| 2019 | Western Michigan 27 – 34 Eastern Michigan |
| 2018 | Eastern Michigan 24 – 27 Western Michigan |