| Ball State | SP+ -25.1 | #133 |
| Ohio | SP+ -11.8 | #109 |
| 2025 | Ohio 14 – 20 Ball State |
| 2024 | Ball State 21 – 42 Ohio |
| 2022 | Ohio 32 – 18 Ball State |
| 2019 | Ohio 34 – 21 Ball State |
| 2018 | Ball State 14 – 52 Ohio |
| 2015 | Ball State 31 – 48 Ohio |
| 2012 | Ohio 27 – 52 Ball State |
| 2011 | Ball State 23 – 20 Ohio |