| Bowling Green | SP+ -15.0 | #118 |
| Western Michigan | SP+ -6.0 | #90 |
| 2024 | Western Michigan 13 – 31 Bowling Green |
| 2023 | Bowling Green 34 – 10 Western Michigan |
| 2022 | Western Michigan 9 – 13 Bowling Green |
| 2019 | Bowling Green 10 – 49 Western Michigan |
| 2018 | Western Michigan 42 – 35 Bowling Green |
| 2015 | Bowling Green 41 – 27 Western Michigan |
| 2014 | Western Michigan 26 – 14 Bowling Green |
| 2011 | Bowling Green 21 – 45 Western Michigan |