| New Mexico | SP+ 0.0 | #68 |
| New Mexico State | SP+ -18.5 | #125 |
| 2025 | New Mexico State 20 – 38 New Mexico |
| 2024 | New Mexico 50 – 40 New Mexico State |
| 2023 | New Mexico State 27 – 17 New Mexico |
| 2022 | New Mexico 9 – 21 New Mexico State |
| 2021 | New Mexico State 25 – 34 New Mexico |
| 2019 | New Mexico State 52 – 55 New Mexico |
| 2018 | New Mexico 42 – 25 New Mexico State |
| 2017 | New Mexico State 30 – 28 New Mexico |