| 2022 | Northern Colorado 10 – 33 Wyoming |
| 2013 | Northern Colorado 7 – 35 Wyoming |
| 1949 | Wyoming 103 – 0 Northern Colorado |
| 1948 | Northern Colorado 0 – 48 Wyoming |
| 1947 | Wyoming 44 – 14 Northern Colorado |
| 1946 | Northern Colorado 0 – 7 Wyoming |
| 1942 | Northern Colorado 0 – 33 Wyoming |
| 1941 | Wyoming 19 – 6 Northern Colorado |