| 2019 | Illinois State 10 – 24 Northern Illinois |
| 2000 | Illinois State 0 – 52 Northern Illinois |
| 1992 | Illinois State 19 – 26 Northern Illinois |
| 1991 | Illinois State 24 – 27 Northern Illinois |
| 1981 | Illinois State 7 – 40 Northern Illinois |
| 1979 | Northern Illinois 33 – 7 Illinois State |
| 1978 | Illinois State 21 – 49 Northern Illinois |
| 1977 | Northern Illinois 7 – 16 Illinois State |