| Memphis | SP+ 0.3 | #67 |
| South Florida | SP+ -1.7 | #74 |
| 2025 | South Florida 31 – 34 Memphis |
| 2024 | Memphis 21 – 3 South Florida |
| 2023 | South Florida 50 – 59 Memphis |
| 2020 | South Florida 33 – 34 Memphis |
| 2019 | Memphis 49 – 10 South Florida |
| 2016 | South Florida 49 – 42 Memphis |
| 2015 | Memphis 24 – 17 South Florida |
| 2014 | South Florida 20 – 31 Memphis |