| Temple | SP+ -9.1 | #99 |
| South Florida | SP+ -1.7 | #74 |
| 2023 | Temple 23 – 27 South Florida |
| 2022 | South Florida 28 – 54 Temple |
| 2021 | Temple 14 – 34 South Florida |
| 2020 | South Florida 37 – 39 Temple |
| 2019 | Temple 17 – 7 South Florida |
| 2018 | South Florida 17 – 27 Temple |
| 2017 | Temple 7 – 43 South Florida |
| 2016 | South Florida 30 – 46 Temple |