| Florida Atlantic | SP+ -6.1 | #91 |
| UL Monroe | SP+ -28.9 | #136 |
| 2012 | Florida Atlantic 14 – 35 UL Monroe |
| 2011 | UL Monroe 26 – 0 Florida Atlantic |
| 2010 | Florida Atlantic 17 – 20 UL Monroe |
| 2009 | UL Monroe 27 – 25 Florida Atlantic |
| 2008 | Florida Atlantic 29 – 28 UL Monroe |
| 2007 | UL Monroe 33 – 30 Florida Atlantic |
| 2006 | Florida Atlantic 21 – 19 UL Monroe |
| 2005 | UL Monroe 28 – 21 Florida Atlantic |