| Florida International | SP+ -14.5 | #115 |
| Florida Atlantic | SP+ -6.1 | #91 |
| 2025 | Florida Atlantic 28 – 38 Florida International |
| 2024 | Florida International 20 – 38 Florida Atlantic |
| 2022 | Florida Atlantic 52 – 7 Florida International |
| 2021 | Florida International 21 – 58 Florida Atlantic |
| 2020 | Florida Atlantic 38 – 19 Florida International |
| 2019 | Florida International 7 – 37 Florida Atlantic |
| 2018 | Florida Atlantic 49 – 14 Florida International |
| 2017 | Florida International 24 – 52 Florida Atlantic |