| 2023 | Idaho State 28 – 78 Utah State |
| 2017 | Idaho State 13 – 51 Utah State |
| 2014 | Idaho State 20 – 40 Utah State |
| 2010 | Idaho State 17 – 38 Utah State |
| 2002 | Idaho State 33 – 38 Utah State |
| 2001 | Idaho State 27 – 28 Utah State |
| 2000 | Idaho State 27 – 24 Utah State |
| 1997 | Idaho State 7 – 41 Utah State |