| Notre Dame | SP+ 26.5 | #3 |
| Navy | SP+ 1.2 | #64 |
| 2025 | Navy 10 – 49 Notre Dame |
| 2024 | Notre Dame 51 – 14 Navy |
| 2023 | Navy 3 – 42 Notre Dame |
| 2022 | Notre Dame 35 – 32 Navy |
| 2021 | Navy 6 – 34 Notre Dame |
| 2019 | Navy 20 – 52 Notre Dame |
| 2018 | Notre Dame 44 – 22 Navy |
| 2017 | Navy 17 – 24 Notre Dame |