| Penn State | SP+ 16.2 | #17 |
| Northwestern | SP+ 5.1 | #49 |
| 2025 | Northwestern 22 – 21 Penn State |
| 2023 | Penn State 41 – 13 Northwestern |
| 2022 | Northwestern 7 – 17 Penn State |
| 2017 | Penn State 31 – 7 Northwestern |
| 2015 | Penn State 21 – 23 Northwestern |
| 2014 | Northwestern 29 – 6 Penn State |
| 2012 | Northwestern 28 – 39 Penn State |
| 2011 | Penn State 34 – 24 Northwestern |