| Oklahoma State | SP+ 6.9 | #39 |
| West Virginia | SP+ -1.3 | #72 |
| 2024 | West Virginia 38 – 14 Oklahoma State |
| 2023 | Oklahoma State 48 – 34 West Virginia |
| 2022 | West Virginia 24 – 19 Oklahoma State |
| 2021 | Oklahoma State 24 – 3 West Virginia |
| 2020 | West Virginia 13 – 27 Oklahoma State |
| 2019 | Oklahoma State 20 – 13 West Virginia |
| 2018 | West Virginia 41 – 45 Oklahoma State |
| 2017 | Oklahoma State 50 – 39 West Virginia |