| BYU | SP+ 14.9 | #21 |
| Colorado State | SP+ -11.6 | #105 |
| 2010 | BYU 49 – 10 Colorado State |
| 2009 | Colorado State 23 – 42 BYU |
| 2008 | BYU 45 – 42 Colorado State |
| 2007 | Colorado State 16 – 35 BYU |
| 2006 | BYU 24 – 3 Colorado State |
| 2005 | Colorado State 14 – 24 BYU |
| 2004 | BYU 31 – 21 Colorado State |
| 2003 | Colorado State 58 – 13 BYU |