| 2024 | Northern Arizona 10 – 22 Arizona |
| 2023 | Northern Arizona 3 – 38 Arizona |
| 2021 | Northern Arizona 21 – 19 Arizona |
| 2019 | Northern Arizona 41 – 65 Arizona |
| 2017 | Northern Arizona 24 – 62 Arizona |
| 2015 | Northern Arizona 13 – 77 Arizona |
| 2013 | Northern Arizona 0 – 35 Arizona |
| 2011 | Northern Arizona 10 – 41 Arizona |