| Oklahoma State | SP+ 6.9 | #39 |
| Tulsa | SP+ -6.1 | #91 |
| 2025 | Tulsa 19 – 12 Oklahoma State |
| 2024 | Oklahoma State 45 – 10 Tulsa |
| 2021 | Tulsa 23 – 28 Oklahoma State |
| 2020 | Tulsa 7 – 16 Oklahoma State |
| 2019 | Oklahoma State 40 – 21 Tulsa |
| 2017 | Tulsa 24 – 59 Oklahoma State |
| 2011 | Oklahoma State 59 – 33 Tulsa |
| 2010 | Tulsa 28 – 65 Oklahoma State |